Eight scenes. Twenty minutes. The part of the deal nobody walks you through.
The salesperson left twenty minutes ago. The finance manager just sat down. The number on the screen feels close enough to about right that you stopped doing math somewhere on page two.
This is the moment the deal is made or lost — not in the showroom, not on the test drive, but in the fifteen-minute window where six pages of paperwork translate into sixty payments. You’ve never seen most of these line items before. You won’t see them again until the next car.
The dealership has been here a thousand times. You’ve been here twice in your life.
“Sign here, initial there, this is a great deal.”
The quote said 6.2%. The contract says 9.8%. That’s an extra $4,700 in interest over the 72-month term.
15 of 51 U.S. jurisdictions publish a verified statutory cap on the dealer documentation fee, from $85 to $800. One caps it by a statutory formula whose current figure no agency publishes. 2 regulate it without a dollar cap. 21 are confirmed not to cap it. For the remaining 12 we could not verify the current rule or figure, and say so rather than guess. The doc fee is dealer revenue, not a tax. Yours went up $400 between the quote and the contract.
Typical range $200–$600. GAP can be genuinely useful when the loan is large relative to the vehicle's value, the down payment is small, or negative equity is being rolled in. The same coverage is often much cheaper from your own insurer or a credit union, and it is never required to get the loan.
Typical range $300–$700. Road-hazard coverage pays for tire and wheel damage that auto insurance usually does not. It is worth more on vehicles with expensive low-profile tires and alloy wheels, and less on an economy car with inexpensive tires.
Typical range $0–$50. Etching itself costs very little and can be done with a retail kit. Where a large price is attached, it is usually for a theft-benefit contract that pays a dealer credit, not cash, if the car is stolen and not recovered.
The Red Flags above are derived from one illustrative contract. The numbers below are the industry pattern they belong to.
15 of 51 U.S. jurisdictions publish a verified statutory cap on the dealer documentation fee, from $85 to $800. One caps it by a statutory formula whose current figure no agency publishes. 2 regulate it without a dollar cap. 21 are confirmed not to cap it. For the remaining 12 we could not verify the current rule or figure, and say so rather than guess.
Average dealer markup on vin etching, across roughly 3 million add-on products. Average dealer markup ran from 83% on service contracts to 325% on vin etching.
Every Carlarity report flags the APR delta, the inflated doc fee, and every add-on the dealer hopes you won’t notice — before you sit at the desk.
We use our own analytics to improve Carlarity. With your permission we also let Google, Meta, TikTok and Reddit set cookies to measure whether our ads work. Decline and nothing is set — your reports work either way. Change your mind any time under Privacy choices.